357 vs 10mm bear
Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...On the factory made ammo, Buffalo Bore has some serious 357M hard-cast ammo with a power factor (MxV) which edges out 10mm (highest factory I could find) by about 8%. So they are both close...For self-brewed, no idea as I don't reload, but will be "watching" the thread. Member: NRA, GOA, ANJRPC, VCDL. "To be born free is an accident.Doing a ballistic test against to see which cartridge is best against a "dangerous animal" (unspecific) between the .357 Magnum, 10mm auto and .44 Magnum. Am...
Did you know?
Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.However, I've seen a video of a park ranger shooting an attacking grizzly, at bear wrestling range, repeatedly with a .357 magnum with hollow points. No effect on the bear! You might feel more comfortable with the 10mm but I honestly feel you would be safer with the bear spray; the 10mm might just make her angry - the spray could disable her ...Muzzle Energy - 414 ft. lbs. Underwood Ammo 357 Sig 147 Grain XTP Jacketed Hollow Point. Muzzle Velocity - 1250 fps. Muzzle Energy - 510 ft. lbs. Underwood Ammo 10mm 200 Grain XTP Jacketed Hollow Point. Muzzle Velocity - 1250 fps. Muzzle Energy - 694 ft. lbs. FNH 5.7x28mm 40 Grain Hornady V-Max. Muzzle Velocity - 2034 fps.Price: $799. Variety is a good thing when it comes to bear defense handguns, and Sig Sauer's new P320 XTen is a welcome addition to the market of 10mm handguns. The P320 series features mostly 9mm models, and has become a big winner for Sig. This is partly because of its versatility.Alaska Geologist Pistol Defense failure June 20, 2010, Grizzly Bear, .357 Magnum. ... I’d prefer and XD 10mm for large bear country, too. 15 rounds of FMJ is a wise defense here, also. I live in ...In reality the best trail gun is a short barrel rifle , like the Win 94 in 30-3010mm vs .357 mag Underwood Xtreme Penetrators for Bear Protection? Alaskan Ballistics. 38.8K subscribers. Subscribed. 3.5K. 127K views 2 years ago. 10mm …As institutional investing slows down and the spotlight on business sustainability shines brighter than ever, startups are putting off new rounds longer and longer. This may seem l...Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...Since the 44 Magnum always beats out the 357 Magnum in terms of stopping power, it comes as no surprise that it trounces the newer 10mm as well. ... the 44 Mag's definitive stopping power will prove more effective for boar, deer, and even bear. A semi-auto 10mm handgun naturally offers increased shot capacity, a faster rate of fire, and an ...The Ultimate .357 Magnum Load for Bear Defense • Discover the ultimate .357 Magnum load for bear defense in this captivating video. Learn why the .357 Magnum...The .357 SIG offers a few advantages over the 10mm cartridge. Firstly, it allows for higher magazine capacity due to its narrower design. Secondly, the .357 SIG typically produces less recoil, making it easier to handle and control. Lastly, the .357 SIG is known for its excellent penetration capabilities, making it suitable for certain law ...The same applies for .45 Super; big bullets start to drop earlier. 10mm is typically more expensive than .45 ACP even in the best of times. If the typical box of 50 hardball practice rounds is $20 to $25 for .45 ACP, it can be upward of $35 for a box of 50 in 10mm depending on brand and box. But expect to pay more.10mm Auto or 44 Magnum for Bear defense, that is the question! Revolver or high capacity automatic? I note actual Bear charges that people have used pistols...The 10mm was designed in part by Colonel Jeff Cooper, a marine, firearms instructor, and 1911 lover who was looking to improve on the .45 ACP cartridge. ... Started with an S&W .357 wheel gun and then to the 4506 .45's. Then in the early 90's it was off on the Beretta adventure for 10 years with the model 96 in .40. And then back to the S&W ...2. Smith & Wesson 610. Chambered in 10mm, the Smith and Wesson model 610 is a good choice for bear defense. Not only is this handgun capable of firing a 10mm round, but is also adaptable to the 40 caliber cartridge. Additionally, this handgun comes in both 4 inch and 6.5 inch barrel configurations.There are fewer pistol choices and it has a stout recoil that seriously limits follow up shots. As mentioned, 10mm is great for hunting but .357sig is great for concealed carry and range shooting. Another plus to .357 sig is that recently I have seen retailers selling HP ammo for cheap prices to clear them out.A hopped up .44 Mag. load, such as the Buffalo Bore 340-grain +P+ hard cast flat nose bullet generates a whopping 1,533 foot-pounds of energy at the muzzle. Compare that to their 10mm Auto mono-metal Dangerous Game load that produces 607 foot-pounds of energy with a 190-grain bullet at 1,200 fps. By that yardstick, the 10mm Auto seems pitiful ...The .357 Sig is good for lightweight bullets, but the 10mm in the original Norma loading (200gr. jhp @ 1200fps) is an excellent self defense/hunting load for everything up to brown bears. Some folks carry it as a backup for grizzlies, but I'm not convinced that it's completely adequate. In a strong enough firearm, a load could be developed to ...10mm- Good woods option. Just know that most affordable 10mm will still be expensive, and all you'll really get is a 40sw. 357sig- Fun, precise, but financially impractical. There are 9mm and 40sw defense rounds that mirror 357sig ballistically.The 10mm packs a stronger punch and excels in long-distance shooting, while the .357 Magnum is known for its versatility and unfaltering performance. Nevertheless, the choice between these two stalwarts depends heavily on the individual’s needs, experience, and preference.Chuke tests 44 Mag and 10mm Underwood Extreme Penetrator on his actual Grizzly Bear Skull to dispel the urban myth that a bears skull will ward off these kin...
Almost any center fire cartridge of 357 bore or larger with a very hard, non-expanding, flat-nosed bullet will pierce a bear's skull with direct /frontal (between the eyes) hits. From the side angle, shoot them right at the bottom of the ear canal. These two shots are instant death if you are using the correct ammo.The 10mm Auto’s velocity compared to the .357 Magnum will be slightly slower due to the fact that many of the bullet weights will be heavier than those of the .357 Magnum. So, on a pure maximum velocity standpoint, the .357 Magnum round is the winner. Energy – when comparing the energy that these two rounds pack, the winner is …The 357mag is capable of the same energy, if not more, than the 10mm. You 10mm worshippers are ridiculous. I never compared the 10mm to the .357. The statement was inferior to the 9mm, .40, & .45. I actually quoted it. If you knew how to read the quote on my post, maybe you would have seen that.The 10mm was originally developed to create a semi-auto cartridge that emulated the ballistic and terminal performance of the 357 Magnum. Since the 44 Magnum always beats out the 357 Magnum in terms of stopping power, it comes as no surprise that it trounces the newer 10mm as well. But here’s the thing: The 10mm is by no means a weak cartridge.Yeah, .357 mag is more powerful, but 10MM is a lot more capacity. A 10mm hardcast out of 5"+ barrel is adequate stopping power for a black bear. I've dropped two with 10mm. I don't shoot a ton with a revolver but I personally would feel more confident with follow up shots with an autoloader.
38 posts · Joined 2015. #1 · Aug 8, 2015. I am trying to decide whether to carry a Super Blackhawk .44 mag. with 3.75 inch barrel or a Magnum Research .454 Casull with 5 inch barrel as grizzly repellant flyfishing the Rockies. At the moment I am thinking either would be loaded with 300 grain or heavier hard cast lead bullets,etc.Originally Posted by Just a HunterI think it was Phil Shoemaker IIR who wrote of bear protection with a pistol. His daughter carried a 357 loaded with 180g bullets. He said it was enough to penetrated the skull of a bear, a brown bear, but with all things it took a cool head to make the ...…
Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs. Originally Posted by Just a HunterI thin. Possible cause: Nine shots of FMJ to the forehead will put a bear down. If you're still no.
This is no 40 vs 45 thread. More a "40" can pretty much hang with the 10mm in long barrels for bear defense, If the 220g and 230g bullets were more available and would stabilize better in the 10mm twist rates. This may be different. Pushing a hardcast WFN 200g@1200-1250 is just hard to beat in the .40/10mm bore.The 10mm starts out slightly bigger before expanding. The .357 has a wider selection of bullet styles readily available, since most .40 caliber bullets are designed for reliable feeding in shell chuckers which puts constraints on the design. 125gr. Gold Dot JHP @ 1600fps - 12.75" / .69".
A head to head 10mm Auto vs. 357 Magnum is nearly too close to call. ... The 10 is often found using 180 grain bullets while the 357 uses a 125 grain bullet. Heavy grain bear-type loads range up ...Also, max budget is 1k. The guns I'm looking at right now are. 10mm Glock 20 Glock 40 Sig p220 Some 1911 in 10mm-Ruger, Smith and Wesson, Springfield ronin, colt delta elite if I can find one for a decent price. 357 Ruger gp100 Smith 586/686. 45 super HK 45 (would do USP but my smedium hands prob wouldn't work great with its chonky grip)The 357 SIG costs a lot more money than the 40 S&W does. As of this writing a box of 20 40 S&W HST hollow points costs $38.99. A similar box of the 357 SIG HST will cost $41.99. The difference is even bigger with the practice ammunition. A box of Federal American Eagle 40s will run you $31.99 while the same box in 357 SIG will be $71.99.
In fact, many people believe that the 45 colt .357 magnum vs. 44 Magnum with Fort Scott Tumble Upon Impact Ammunition. 10mm Glock 40 3 Long Barrel Length Velocities. ... 155gr Federal Terminal Ascent.243 Winchester 95gr Federal Fusion Thompson Center Venture. 6.5×284 NORMA BARNES 127gr LRX . 10mm vs. .41 magnum for Bears. Alaskan Ballistics. 226 Videos. 100% . 5 Likes. April 1, 2021. By ...6 Likes. August 19, 2021. By Alaskan Ballistics. 1 Comments. 10mm vs. .357 Magnum for bear protection? in Episode 3 we have Underwood Xtreme Penetrators and more redneck science. What do you use for … Depending on which website you go to there seems to The glock 20 holds 15 rounds flush mags and gen 5 comes milled fr It can get your attention, but nothing like the 10mm. The 9mm generates around 4 ft./lbs. of energy .. ok, maybe up to 6 or so depending on the load and the weight of the pistol firing it. The 10mm starts at around 10 ft./lbs. and can go up to 12 or more. That’s double the felt recoil of the 9mm. Go 10mm all the way because penetration is kin Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a 10mm Auto round averages out to 550 ft-lb, while a .454 Casull round averages out to about 1700 ft-lb. One way to think about this is as such: a foot-pound is a unit of energy equal to the amount of energy required to raise a weight of one pound a distance of one foot. So a 10mm Auto round exits the barrel ...In 2018 I DLP'ed a black bear boar with a GP-100 .357 magnum (158 grain hard cast at ~1250 fps). In 2003 it was a bull moose with a SW 329PD (ported).44 mag (305 grain hard cast Cor-Bon). ... I've moved to a 10mm with 220g hard cast now but only for the reason of quick reloads. Our family has gotten 6 moose permits of my life and 4 of those ... Testing out 10mm, .357 Magnum and .44 Magnum usThe .357 magnum revolver with hardcast bullets has even more &The .357 Magnum, having greater case capacity, h In reality the best trail gun is a short barrel rifle , like the Win 94 in 30-30The Super Redhawk is available in 6-, 7-, and 9-inch barrels. The extra weight and barrel length make the recoil a smidge easier to handle. The Super Redhawk comes chambered for .44 Rem Mag, .454 Casull, 10mm, and .458 Ruger. When loaded with the right ammo, all are capable of bear-stopping cartridges. The .357 Magnum, having greater case capacity, has the pote A .357 Magnum is formidable as hell, but that doesn't mean anything when you can't hit a charging bear. For my money, I wouldn't trust a 9mm, even though it seems to pass the test here. I'd go a little heavier — my .357 Magnum is the likely choice for me — and practice, practice, practice. It doesn't hurt if you have bear spray ... Top 10mm Loads For Bear Defense. Underwood 10mm[A more accurate comparison would be to par the 10mm AYeah, .357 mag is more powerful, but 10MM is a lot more capacity. 9mm VS a Bear Thread starter thebusinessend; ... .41mag is considered the minimum for bear hunting. 10mm w/ 15rds+ or 200/230gr hardcast/FMJ is considered the minimum for bear protection. ... The most powerful handgun I own is a .357 mag. Therefore, I'd bring bear spray and then shoot the thing. RI_John. Joined Mar 12, 2009 Messages 2,466 Likes 618The .357 mag is about the minimum in power for protection against large predators or against large game. That doesn't mean that It's ineffective, just that there has to be a cutoff somewhere. The 10mm …